Coldwell Banker Home Page

Local Realty Service Provided By: Coldwell Banker Finger Lakes

Property view

5892 Whitney Bay Road, 
Mayville, NY 14757

$430,000


3

Beds


1

Bath


1,008

Sq Ft


Single Family

Sold

Listed by

Julie Barry

Bought with EXP-Premier Listings Team

Century 21 Turner Brokers

716-763-7506

MLS#

R1697077

Source:

NY GENRIS

Sorry, we are unable to map this address

About This Home

5892 Whitney Bay Road

Turnkey lakefront cottage with 80 feet on frontage! This 4 season lake home currently operates as a short term rental(currently sleeps 9), with an exceptional longstanding rental history. Tucked away in a private and peaceful setting, this 3 bedroom home is a true hidden gem. Inside you will find updated finishes, a newly remodeled bathroom, and a loft-style upstairs bedroom that adds charm and extra sleeping space. The kitchen features granite countertops, and beautiful wood floors that run throughout the home. Enjoy looking at the lake in either the screened in sunroom, or off of the back deck. A heated shed with electricity and an additional half bathroom adds additional storage, or the opportunity to be converted into a bunk-house. Home is being sold fully furnished, minus a couple items. Major improvements include: converted into 4 season cottage, close cell foam insulation, converted from propane to natural gas, new water heater, added washer & dryer capabilities, new well, loft fully remodeled, new flooring throughout entire home, new water pump, updated kitchen and fully remodeled bathroom, replaced outdoor decks, replaced windows, and custom blinds for screened porch. Whether you are looking for a move in ready vacation home or a turnkey rental, look no further!

Home Facts

Single Family

1 Bath

3 Bedrooms

Built in 1953

Price Summary

499,000

$495 per Sq. Ft.

MLS #:

R1697077

Sold:

September 14, 2026


Rooms & Interior

Bedrooms

Total Bedrooms:

3

Bathrooms

Total Bathrooms:

1

Full Bathrooms:

1

Interior

Living Area:

1,008 Sq. Ft.


Structure

Structure

Architectural Style:

Cottage

Building Area:

1,008 Sq. Ft.

Year Built:

1953


Lot

Lot Size (Sq. Ft):

14,400


Finances & Disclosures

Finances

Price:

$499,000

Price per Sq. Ft:

$495 per Sq. Ft.

Source:NY GENRIS
The information being provided by New York State Alliance Of Mlss is for the consumer’s personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should therefore be independently verified. © 2026 New York State Alliance Of Mlss All rights reserved.