An exceptional opportunity in the heart of historic Elmer. This versatile two-story duplex offers two 2-bedroom units, each with its own private entry, private laundry, and separate utilities. Unit 1 features one full bath, while Unit 2 offers one full and one half baths. Important updates include two 100,000 BTU Crown Aruba 83% efficiency natural gas boilers installed in 2014, one serving each unit, with the original above-ground oil tanks removed at that time. The electrical system was also brought up to code, and a new 1,000-gallon septic tank and 1,000-gallon dosing tank were installed. The large semi-finished basement offers approximately 847 sq. ft. of additional flexible space with a wood-burning fireplace, built-in storage, and an original “Italia” kitchen. Traditionally, these second kitchens were common in many Italian-American homes and served as gathering spaces for cooking, entertaining, and family celebrations. While this kitchen reflects its era, it adds a unique piece of the home’s history and could be incorporated into a future game room, entertaining space, secondary living area, private office, or simply used for additional storage. A garage adds even more functionality. Ideal for an investor looking to expand a portfolio or a savvy buyer who wants to occupy one unit while generating income from the other. Enjoy the character and small-town charm of Elmer, with local shops, dining, and everyday conveniences nearby. Flexible, practical, and full of potential.