Coldwell Banker Home Page
Local Realty Service Provided By: Coldwell Banker Kaiser Real Estate

5065 Sugar Cay Court, 
Carmel, IN 46033

$855,000


4

Beds


4

Baths


4,084

Sq Ft


Single Family

Sold

Listed by

Mike Deck

Joel Rust

Bought with eXp Realty, LLC

Berkshire Hathaway Home

317-595-2100

MLS#

22091596

Source:

IN MIBOR

Sorry, we are unable to map this address

About This Home

5065 Sugar Cay Court

Nestled on a .47-acre corner lot in Bayhill at Waterstone, 5065 Sugar Cay Court reflects the timeless appeal and enduring quality that define one of Carmel's most established neighborhoods. With 4,075 finished square feet, a screened porch, deck, finished daylight basement, and 3-car side-load garage, this custom home offers the space, warmth, and thoughtful layout that make everyday living feel both comfortable and refined. A two-story entry opens to formal living and dining rooms and a warm family room with a gas fireplace for relaxed evenings at home. The eat-in kitchen is designed for both daily living and entertaining, featuring Merillat cabinetry, a Maytag in-wall convection oven, built-in microwave, pantry, and adjoining sun room filled with natural light. Crown molding, cased openings, and unified oak flooring bring continuity and classic style throughout the main level. Upstairs, the primary suite offers a private retreat with a tray ceiling, sitting area, two walk-in closets, dual sinks, jetted tub, and separate shower. Three additional bedrooms, each with walk-in closets, plus two additional full baths provide comfortable space for family and guests. The finished daylight basement adds flexibility for recreation, a home office, or additional lounge space, while still offering unfinished storage. Recent updates include roof, paint, and carpeting in 2021, A/C in 2024, powder room refresh in 2024, and gas water heater in 2025. Exterior highlights include brick and composite siding, Pella replacement windows in key living areas and throughout the upper level, a replaced front door, exposed aggregate sidewalk and front porch, in-ground irrigation, and landscape lighting. Waterstone amenities include a clubhouse, pool, playground, tennis, pickleball, and walking paths around Lake Waterstone.

Home Facts

Single Family

4 Baths

4 Bedrooms

Built in 1995

Price Summary

839,000

$205 per Sq. Ft.

MLS #:

22091596

Sold:

May 1, 2026


Rooms & Interior

Bedrooms

Total Bedrooms:

4

Bathrooms

Total Bathrooms:

4

Full Bathrooms:

3

Interior

Living Area:

4,084 Sq. Ft.


Structure

Structure

Building Area:

4,541 Sq. Ft.

Year Built:

1995


Lot

Lot Size (Sq. Ft):

20,473


Finances & Disclosures

Finances

Price:

$839,000

Price per Sq. Ft:

$205 per Sq. Ft.

Source:IN MIBOR
Copyright 2026 Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of Realtors. All rights reserved. Listings courtesy of Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of Realtors as distributed by MLS GRID. Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of Realtors provides content displayed here (“provided content”) on an “as is” basis and makes no representations or warranties regarding the provided content, including, but not limited to those of non-infringement, timeliness, accuracy, or completeness. Individuals and companies using information presented are responsible for verification and validation of information they utilize and present to their customers and clients. Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of Realtors will not be liable for any damage or loss resulting from use of the provided content or the products available through Portals, IDX, VOW, and/or Syndication. Recipients of this information shall not resell, redistribute, reproduce, modify, or otherwise copy any portion thereof without the expressed written consent of Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of Realtors.