As an experienced agent since 2001 with Coldwell Banker Schmitt in Marathon, I specialize in the Middle and Upper Keys real estate market. I lived in Marathon for 26 years and have been in Islamorada since 2015. As a Realtor, educating my customers about buying or selling homes and properties in the Florida Keys is my top priority! My goal is to give you all the information I can and to...
    As an experienced agent since 2001 with Coldwell Banker Schmitt in Marathon, I specialize in the Middle and Upper Keys real estate market. I lived in Marathon for 26 years and have been in Islamorada since 2015. As a Realtor, educating my customers about buying or selling homes and properties in the Florida Keys is my top priority! My goal is to give you all the information I can and to guide you so that you make the best decision possible when you decide to buy or sell property in the Florida Keys! I excel at staying in touch and responding to your emails or calls promptly, weekday or weekend. I am always a top producing agent every year in my office and am a member of the Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Elite Agent Circle (top 100 agents Keys-wide).

    My Client Testimonials

    Amy did a fantastic job for us and went the extra mile. She was very professional and not the pushy type we've encountered in the past. You should be proud to have an Amy Puto on your team. Doug and Lisa C., Baltimore, MD
    Amy did a great job asking questions in regards to the list of features we had to have to consider a property. She was the only agent in the Keys that I met that was both a great listener and great at asking the right questions! Amy did a fantastic job! John and Janet M., Englewood & Islamorada, FL
    Amy's understanding of a client's wants and needs are a testament to her professionalism. Roberta H., Key Colony Beach, FL
    Excellent representation and very smooth transaction. Chris and Angela D, Circleville, OH
    Amys website has been invaluable as well as her weekly communications! She was a great resource. Darcy D., Portsmouth, NH
    Amy has been great to work with! She keeps us informed! Amy's website is fantastic! Brian and Eileen W., Bonita Springs, FL
    Amy is simply the best! Keith and Lynn S., Hattiesburg, MS
    Amy was amazing to work with and will gladly refer her to anyone. Connor and Natalie F., Tavernier, FL
    Amy Puto is a top-notch agent! She is personable and knowledgeable and a delight to work with! She is organized and dependable, qualities that we truly appreciate! Amy goes above and beyond what is expected and we will certainly recommend her to others. Paul and Vickie C., Duck Key, FL
    There really is not enough room to express how happy we are with Amy. If one thing stands out, it is she was always there whenever we had to get a hold of her, always pleasant, always helpful with any questions we had. Amy certainly knows Marathon real estate. Amy was outstanding. Our experience with Amy has been nothing short of fantastic. Tom and Leslie C., Euclid, OH
    As a former Florida resident who still has a Florida real estate license, I've worked with many real estate professionals over the years. Amy Puto tops my list of Realtors I've worked with. She is professional, dedicated and fantastic to work with. Thank you Amy! Michael W., Newbury, MA
    Amy never gave up on these 2 boat slips. She was always friendly, polite and professional. I have recommended her on my Facebook page! Linda W., Naples, FL
    Amy Puto did a great job. I have bought and sold many properties, Amy is one of the best. Anthony C., Roxbury, NY
    I loved Amy the first moment I met her! She was everything in a sales person that I expected! Cathy R., Massapequa, NY
    Thank you Amy. She was very thorough. Jerry's pictures are awesome. Her website and knowledge of the area sets her apart. Bob S. and Darcy D., Portsmouth, NH
    From first contact through closing and follow through, Amy Puto was truly professional, proactive and extremely thorough. Working with Amy was a wonderful experience. Michael and Susan S., Jupiter, FL
    Our experience with Amy was one of the best weve ever had with an agent. She was very personable and knowledgeable. She understood our needs and desires and offered other properties that also created interest. Ray and Carolyne W., Lewisburg, WV
    Amy was outstanding with great communication and follow up. Highly recommend her! Tom and Kim D., Belvidere, IL
    Amy, We are very happy for having used your services and found you very professional and honest. We will be delighted to recommend you to our family and friends. Tony and Cristina, Palmetto Bay, FL
    Amy is amazing! She truly understands the FL Keys market and was a great asset in my search for an investment property and vacation home. She is very responsive and professional and truly went above and beyond throughout the buying process. Thank you Amy! Hammad Q., Rockville, MD
    Amy is an excellent agent. Was always available, answered every question. Went above and beyond what we expected. She is a quality person and it shines right through into all aspects of her life. Greg and Trish F., Perrysburg, OH and Key Colony Beach, FL
    Amy it was a pleasure to work with you, selling a home is a big emotional part of one's life but you kept everyone under control. You made a stressful time go so very easy. Your professionalism was very appreciated, staying in touch and returning phone calls and emails promptly. You went the extra mile for us more then once. I would not hesitate to work with you again and I will recommend you any chance I get. I wish you a Healthy New Year! Very truly yours, Mark P., New York, NY
    Amy is awesome. Knowledgeable, helpful, her website is great and keeps people up to date. She could have given up on us long ago but stuck with us. I would recommend her to anyone. We love Amy Puto! Jim and Betty H., Temple, TX and Key Colony Beach, FL.
    I absolutely could not have chosen a more professional, knowledgeable, courteous agent than Amy Puto. She excels in every aspect of being a real estate agent. Amy actually goes over and beyond. Janie R., from Pensacola, FL but now a full time Marathon resident!
    I called Amy Puto in March 2018 after seeing her advertisement for Tranquility Bay. We ended up meeting her in April and she took time to show us a variety of places. We live in Colorado and she was awesome to work with and kept us in the know all the time. Carrie and Tony R., Ft. Collins, CO (Carrie and Tony closed on their new condo in August!)
    Amy is my favorite and best real estate person I have every dealt with! Jim and Laura M., Kalkaska, MI
    Amy is an absolute pleasure to do business with. She is honest and professional throughout the buying and selling process. After a previous transaction with Amy, we knew there wasn't anyone else that we wanted to represent us in the sale of our home. Laura K., Michael K., Paul M., Sarasota, FL
    Amy Puto is a pleasure to work with. She takes the time to know you and understand what you are looking for. Greg and Joy C., Franklin, TN
    This is my 4th transaction with Amy. If every agent on your staff is a good as her, you have a great crew! Her follow-up, organization, and attention to detail, even the smallest ones, are incredible! Howard and Sheri, Key Colony Beach, FL
    Amy was great to work with! She is very easy to get a hold of, responds quickly and is knowledgeable. We would recommend her to others and plan to use her in the future. John and Joyce G., Berlin, MD
    Amy is an amazing real estate agent: highly qualified and dedicated to her work. She was a pleasure to work with and made the process run smoothly. It was a blessing to have found Amy and work with her. Cristina M. and Alejandro C., Miami, FL
    Amy was the best agent we have every worked with. We appreciated her patience, follow-up, anticipation of our needs and honesty. You are lucky to have her! Richard and Michele W., Ft. Myers, FL
    Amy truly went above & beyond for me. I have dealt with several realtors in my lifetime, but she was by far the best Ive ever used. She sold my duplex on KCB before it even was officially listed, and worked hard to get me in my new condo on KCB. Highly recommended. Howard S., Haslett, MI
    Amy's knowledge of the Middle Keys communities and established professional contacts, make her the obvious choice of which agent we wanted to work with. After losing a few foreclosure bids/deals in Hawks Cay and Tranquility Bay, she went out and found us an unlisted property and made the deal get done. Great job! Russell B. and Tonie D., Brentwood, TN
    Amy is AWESOME! We have known and worked with Amy since 2010. She represented us when we bought our house and then when we sold it. She is so great to work with because she really knows the industry and the area inside and out. She comes across as low pressure which is really nice, but she really gets the job done! From the beginning I knew we could trust her. She got the deals done and to our satisfaction. On a personal note, she is just a really great person, warm, funny and caring. We really like her and consider her a friend. When we are ready to buy again in the Keys, we will definitely be calling Amy!!! Brooke J., Huntingtown, MD
    Amy Puto was recommended to us by a local contractor when we finally decided to sell our vacant lot in Sombero (were from Chicago, IL). Amys expertise was invaluable in pricing and negotiating the sale of the lot. Amy even spoke with, and got, a not-so-nice neighboring homeowner to move his belongings from off of our vacant lot onto his own property! Amy's use of DocuSign made the entire transaction virtual. We highly recommend Amy Puto for your real estate needs in the Keys. Kevin K., Chicago, IL
    My husband and I own some real estate in the Keys and we are always interested in how the real estate market is doing in that area. We have been subscribing to Amy Puto's Weekly Market Report for a couple of years now in order to stay in the loop. She is SUPER thorough and has very up-to-date information included in her reports. She is extremely knowledgeable. I highly recommend subscribing. I have passed her information along to as many people as I can, and of course I'm trying to convince all of my northern friends to subscribe and start scoping out their retirement and/or income properties! I am sure that in the event we need to buy or sell in the future, she is the one we will be calling. I wish all Realtors loved their jobs the way Amy loves hers! Dana K., Michigan
    You are terrific and the most professional, prepared and attentive realtor I have ever dealt with. Should the need arise for me or any of my friends to look for property in the Keys, I will not hesitate to recommend you. Thanks again. Scott L., Miami, FL

    My Experience

    • Licensed Florida Realtor with Coldwell Banker Schmitt since 2001
    • One of the top salespersons in my office (Marathon) every year

    My Credentials and Memberships

    • Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co. Elite Agent Circle - I am proud to say I am a member, which includes the TOP 100 real estate agents in the entire Keys! (All companies, not just Coldwell Banker)
    • Coldwell Banker Previews Property Specialist - awarded to those agents who specialize in luxury properties. In our market, those are homes priced at $1M+.
    • 2019 Coldwell Banker International President's Elite. Awarded to the Top 2% of 85,000 agents with Coldwell Banker world-wide.
    • 2018 Coldwell Banker International Presidents Circle. Awarded to the Top 5% of 85,000 agents with Coldwell Banker world-wide.
    • 2016 Coldwell Banker International President's Elite. Awarded to the Top 2% of 85,000 agents with Coldwell Banker world-wide.
    • 2015 Coldwell Banker International President's Circle. Awarded to the Top 6% of 85,000 agents with Coldwell Banker world-wide.
    • 2014 Coldwell Banker International President's Elite - Awarded to the Top 2% of 85,000 agents with Coldwell Banker world-wide.
    • 2013 Coldwell Banker International President's Circle - Awarded to the Top 6% of 85,000 agents with Coldwell Banker world-wide.
    • Member of the National Association of Realtors
    • Member of the Florida Association of Realtors

    My Community Involvement

    • Proud supporter of the Coldwell Banker Schmitt Charitable Foundation

    Local Insights

    Share My Page

    Go Mobile

    Want to take your search on the go and find nearby homes? Download my free mobile app.

    Goto Apple app store to download iOS app Goto Google play store to download the app