Donna Lomenzo

    Donna Lomenzo

    Satisfaction Rating An agent's star rating is the average of all the ratings of their service.
    Over 20 Years Experience. Responsible For Helping Over 1,000 Happy Families Relocate! Call Today For Your Free Marketability Report!
    Donna has been in the Real Estate business since 1997. Donna exemplifies the power and leverage of the Coldwell Banker legacy and brand. Life Long Resident of Long Island that has brokered deals with Sellers and Buyers from the North to the South Shore. Donna was the Owner/Broker of Coldwell Banker Neyland for 10 years. The company was merged with Coldwell Banker M&D Good Life in 2014 forming the perfect partnership to better serve the community.
    Donna was voted Bethpage Best of L.I Best Real Estate Agent for 2019 & 2020

    My Client Reviews

    (35 reviews)
    Overall star rating: 5.0
    Past 3 months: N/A

    Ratings Breakdown

    Star Rating Percentage of reviews with this rating Number of reviews with this rating
    5 stars
    100% of Donna’s ratings: 5 stars
    (35)
    4 stars
    0% of Donna’s ratings: 4 stars
    (0)
    3 stars
    0% of Donna’s ratings: 3 stars
    (0)
    2 stars
    0% of Donna’s ratings: 2 stars
    (0)
    1 stars
    0% of Donna’s ratings: 1 star
    (0)

    Showing All Reviews (35)

    Show only: 5 stars 4 stars 3 stars 2 stars 1 star show all
    2022
    01/24/22
    Cara gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Donna was an absolute pleasure to work with. We were first time home buyers, with a time crunch to find a home. Donna was extremely vigilant, informative, and very much attentive to our needs and finding the perfect something during a hard time to buy. She was top notch in terms of communication, always working around our schedules, and in the end she helped us land something we are hoping extremely happy with. 10/10 recommend!
    Response from Donna
    01/28/22
    Cara you were a delight to work with!! Looking forward to seeing you and your growing family soon!
    2021
    11/04/21
    Charles gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Donna is a knowledgeable professional who possesses an incredible attention to detail. I could not asked for better communicator throughout my selling process. She was responsive to any question, concern or need any time of day or night. I give her my highest recommendation! Charles G.
    10/28/21
    Valerie gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Donna Lomenzo, Realtor, is a fabulously professional Broker located on Long Island. Donna delivers the service you need to buy and/or sell your current home or your home of the future. She is a professional, and will deliver! She is the Broker who knows and understands every aspect of the real estate transaction and will see it through to the end. Easy to reach and responsive to your needs, she will never leave you in the cold! If I hadn't relocated off Long Island, I would certainty use Donna a fourth time to purchase my next home. I highly recommend Donna Lomenzo, the definition of what a real estate broker is!
    10/27/21
    Michael gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Donna was extremely helpful leading the sale of my property. Her attention to detail, urgency and advice was extremely valuable. Thanks for putting my family and I at ease throughout the process.
    10/27/21
    Teresa gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Donna handled the sale of our home very professionally and was very responsive. We highly recommend using Donna for all your real estate needs.
    Response from Donna
    10/27/21
    Thank you!!
    10/27/21
    Christine gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Working with Donna was such a great experience. She was so helpful from start to finish. She really went above and beyond to help with every aspect of our sale and our move! Fantastic!!! Highly recommended
    Response from Donna
    10/27/21
    Thank you Christine!! I absolutely loved your home!!
    10/27/21
    Keith & Debbie gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    My wife and I had the pleasure of working with Donna on the sale of our home and the buying of our new forever home. To say Donna was incredibly helpful throughout the entire process is an understatement. Selling and buying a home is a stressful time. Donna made it a very smooth quick transition. My wife and I loved working with her and I would recommend her to anyone!
    Response from Donna
    10/27/21
    Thank you Keith & Debbie!! I loved working with you both as well!
    10/27/21
    Joe & Jeanne gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Donna was a pleasure to work with. She knows her stuff and sold our house quickly.
    Response from Donna
    10/27/21
    Thank you Joe & Jeanne!
    2020
    09/24/20
    Frank gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Donna is an outstanding real estate agent. The level of service, communications and care she showed during the process of listing, showing and selling my house was exceptional. I have worked with other real estate agents in the past and none of them come close to delivering the level and quality of service Donna has. I highly highly recommend Donna!!
    Response from Donna
    09/28/20
    Thank you Frank! It was a pleasure to work with you and I appreciate your trust in me!
    08/06/20
    Lauren gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    We had never sold a house before and Donna made the whole process effortless and stress free. Donna was highly recommended to us and quickly proved the recommendation was well founded. Her initial presentation was extremely thorough and professional and her advice on list price was spot on. Donna always answered calls, texts and emails promptly, made sure we understood every step of the process and we really felt like she was in our corner making sure the sale stayed on track. We were completely satisfied from start to finish with her professionalism and dedication and would highly recommend!
    Response from Donna
    08/07/20
    Thank you Lauren!! It was a great pleasure to help sell your beautiful home!
    08/06/20
    Ryan gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Donna was an exceptional agent for our home purchase. She kept us well informed throughout the whole process and strongly advocated for our interests throughout. She demonstrated tremendous experience and industry knowledge which helped us to get the house of our dreams, and at a good price. We would highly recommend her to anyone and already have.
    Response from Donna
    08/07/20
    Thank you Ryan! I am so happy for you and Lauren and can not wait to see what improvements you make!
    07/11/20
    Jen gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    I can't say enough about how great Donna was to work with. From our first discussion, she quickly understood what our family wanted and needed (probably before we even knew what we were really looking for!) and we moved quickly from there. From viewing homes, to guidance on a smart offer right through to closing, Donna was always available to answer our questions (day or night!), was always professional, helpful and truly our guide! She helped find resources that we needed to make our quick purchase and move happen -- It was three weeks from offer to close! We never could have done it without Donna.
    Response from Donna
    08/07/20
    Thank you Jen!! I loved working with you from afar!
    2019
    11/30/19
    Margaret gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    From our very first meeting with Donna we felt confident in her abilities as our listing agent. She was there for us every step of the way. Her knowledge of the market was top notch. If you're looking to buy or sell, we highly recommend you reach out to her. You won't be disappointed!
    08/30/19
    Karen gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    being an out of state seller, Donna helped with some technicalities. Most helpful.
    Response from Donna
    09/18/19
    Thank you Karen!
    06/11/19
    Laurie gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    As an out of state seller, Donna was very helpful when we weren't able to be there for utility readings, to finding someone to mow a long overgrown lawn. She was our champion, and we couldn't have been more appreciative of her dedication. From listing to closing, she did it all.
    Response from Donna
    09/18/19
    Thank you! It was great to work with you on this unique home!
    05/30/19
    Joseph gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Donna has helped me buy a condo, sell a condo and most recently, purchase my forever house with my family. There's no other agent my family wants to work with due to Donna's professionalism, experience, positive attitude and personal committment. Shes an amazing agent, a superior person.
    Response from Donna
    05/31/19
    Thank you for the kind words Joe! It has been my pleasure working with you over the years and now with your beautiful family!! Enjoy your new home!
    01/14/19
    Marc gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    I have worked with Donna twice in the last few years and always an awesome experience. Highly recommend, we will be using her again in a few years for sure.
    2018
    12/12/18
    Cari gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Buying a home was one of the most stressful times of my life but I found it thanksnto Donna! Donna helped me figure out where I wanted to be and what was a good fit. She found me my perfect forever home!
    12/03/18
    Gary gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Donna was a great help in selling my brother's house after his death. The sale was complicated by my living in another state. Donna's knowledge of local real estate was invaluable in completing this sale in a timely manner and I appreciate her assistance.
    Response from Donna
    12/05/18
    Thank you Gary! It was a pleasure to help and I am so glad that you can move on as I know this has been a difficult time for you!
    12/02/18
    Deborah gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    From start to finish Donna made buying and selling a breeze. She was readily available to answer any questions we had throughout the whole process.
    Response from Donna
    12/05/18
    Thank you Debbie...I appreciate that you trusted me with your purchase and your sale! It was a great pleasure to work with you and your family!
    10/08/18
    Paul gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Since beginning what people say is one of the most stressful moments of ones life ,'Selling A Home', the entire event was not that at all! When I first met donna Lomenzo at her office I was impressed by the way she assured me that the process will go smoothly. Her professionalism and demeanor never waivers throughout the entire process. Considering I found Sonna without a referral or seeing her advertisement, my experience with her and Caldwell Bank Realestate agency was OUTSTANDING to say the lesser. Donna throughout our professional relationship went over and beyond for me and my wife. Always keeping us informed. That in itself was very calming fir us. I will use Donna for all my future Realestate transactions as well as referring her to all my friends and family. She is A PLUS PLUS IN OUR BOOK.
    08/14/18
    Vicky gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Donna Lomenzo has been our saving grace. She helped us find a home that we love after losing out on two other homes that needed too much work. Donna has been there for me and my husband morning, noon, and night she made herself available to us no matter what time of the day or what day it was. I would do this whole process over again only with her. I highly recommend her.
    Response from Donna
    08/14/18
    Thank you Vicky!!! And thank you for trusting me to help you with this new exciting chapter of your life!
    07/28/18
    Pamela gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Donna was such a pleasure to work with when it came to selling our home. She was very knowledgeable about the area and the market. We appreciated the quick responses to our questions and the respect she had for our home as she brought her prospective buyers through. She felt like a friend helping us through this emotional process all the while working to get the best possible outcome for us.
    Response from Donna
    07/30/18
    Thank you Pam! It was my pleasure to work with you!
    05/29/18
    Diane & Charlie gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    We loved working with Donna. She is smart, very professional, and knows local tradespeople that she can recommend to help the seller get the house ready for sale. Donna was with us every step of the way from the listing, through the open house, the inspection and on to the closing. We are lucky to know her and would highly recommend her to a seller or buyer.
    05/29/18
    Diane & Charlie gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    We loved working with Donna. She is smart, very professional, and knows local tradespeople that she can recommend to help the seller get the house ready for sale. Donna was with us every step of the way from the listing, through the open house, the inspection and on to the closing. We are lucky to know her and would highly recommend her to a seller or buyer.
    04/14/18
    Toni gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Donna is wonderful to work with! I liked her from the moment that I met her and hired her right away to sell my house and help me find a condo. This was a very stressful time in my life having to downsize and go through 4 generations of stuff. I was very overwhelmed and anxious during this time. One thing that made it better was having Donna on my side. She answered every text and phone call and would always try to keep me positive. She talked me down many times, she really puts herself into what she does. She is not only great at real estate transactions, she is also great at helping people remain calm in a very stressful situation. I am so happy that I met her and hired her to help me with one of the biggest moves I've ever made. I intend to keep in touch with Donna, she is a wonderful person!
    02/23/18
    Ron gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Donna is professional, very knowledgeable, very helpful and was able to sell our home quickly. Highly recommended!
    01/17/18
    Rodney gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    It was a pleasure dealing with Donna on my recent home purchase. Even though she wasn't my 'buyers agent' , Donna stayed in constant contact with me ensuring a smooth transaction. I would not hesitate to contract with her to sell my other place when the time comes. Professional, courteous, friendly, and easy to work with. Highly recommend.
    Response from Donna
    01/17/18
    Thank you Rod! It was a pleasure helping you and your daughter!
    2017
    11/12/17
    Debra gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Donna is very professional and very hands on. Any problems that arose (and there were many) she jumped right in to solve them. She also had a very calming effect when my nerves got the best of me. But, I am now happily in my new home and loving it. It was well worth it and Im happy that she was there to help me through all of it.
    10/02/17
    Stuart & Kathryn gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Donna was very professional and gave great advice. She knew exactly what to say to bring out the best features of our home. She was also instrumental in finding a buyer. Will recommend her to all of our friends.
    09/03/17
    Danielle gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Donna was a wonderful real estate agent. We used her to sell our condo and to buy our new forever home. She was very knowledgeable and was always looking out for us. She was there night or day. I would definitely recommend Donna to everyone.
    05/02/17
    Adan gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    There are not enough words to describe what a pleasure it has been to work with Donna in the difficult task of selling one house and purchasing another at the same time. As difficult of a task this can be for anyone to accomplish, Donna was able to perform exceptionally well. My wife and I were able to successfully close on our house we were selling before I had to report to military duty, as well as securing the contract for the home we are purchasing. Donna has worked tirelessly in making sure my wife and I had everything that needed to be done in order to successfully sell our home and purchase another. Donna made herself available to us seven days a week 24 hours a day. Any questions we might of had, no matter how late it was, Donna responded back promptly via email, text, or telephone. I can keep on going explaining in words on how professional and dedicated Donna is as a real estate agent and person, but it would be better for all of you taking the time to read this to experience her professionalism and dedication to duty for yourself. I assure you that you will not be disappointed. Excellent job Donna! Thank you for all that you have done for my family and I.
    05/01/17
    Timothy gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Donna was great!! Always available to us and always got us the answers we were looking for. She took care of all the details and made our purchase and sale very easy. I will recommend her in the future.
    04/30/17
    Joyous gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    We are so happy we chose donna to help us find our first home! She spent so many weekends with us going to open houses and appointments. we had no doubts with her. Donna was always there to answer any questions we had, explained things we didn't understand, and steered us in the right direction. We Highly reccomend Donna! Thank you for everything!
    03/13/17
    Ed gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    I was in the market to buy a second home. I called Alamando off of one of her ads . From the moment I spoke to her I knew I was dealing with a true professional. I chose to work with Donna as my buyers agent. I felt she was honest and trustworthy throughout the entire process and really help me negotiate to get the house that I wanted. She is a true professional from start to finish and I'd highly recommend her to anybody.
    03/13/17
    Jessica gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Best experience with a real estate agent I ever had. Donna was so knowledgeable in every aspect. Definitely would use Donna again!
    03/13/17
    Jessica gave Donna 5 stars out of 5
    Best experience with a real estate agent I ever had. Donna was so knowledgeable in every aspect. Definitely would use Donna again!

    My Experience

    • 18+ years experience
    • Associate Real Estate Broker
    • Past Owner/Broker of Coldwell Banker Neyland Realty
    • Have helped over 1,000 families make a move
    • Specializing in Residential Real Estate

    My Credentials and Memberships

    • International President's Circle (top 3% of all sales associates worldwide)
    • Certified Buyer Representative
    • Certified Negotiation Specialist
    • Smart Home Certified
    • Associate Real Estate Broker and former Broker/Owner Coldwell Banker Neyland Realty
    • Long Island Board of Realtors Member
    • National Association of Realtors Member
    • New York State Association of Realtors Member

    My Community Involvement

    • Ovarian Cancer Research Fund Alliance Volunteer

    Local Insights

    Follow Me

    Share My Page

    Go Mobile

    Want to take your search on the go and find nearby homes? Download my free mobile app.

    Goto Apple app store to download iOS app Goto Google play store to download the app

    Resources

    Any services or products provided by third parties are not provided by, affiliated with, or related to Coldwell Banker Real Estate LLC or its affiliated companies.