Amity Justice

    Amity Justice

    Satisfaction Rating An agent's star rating is the average of all the ratings of their service.
    Whether your interest in the Rim Country is a full-time home, part-time getaway, or you are ready to list your home for someone else to build their mountain dreams, I truly believe the Rim Country area has something for everyone and I want to help you achieve your desired goals.

    A Payson resident since 1996 and now full-time Pine resident, I have a strong business and customer service background and a love for the area and local wildlife. I am an involved member of the community and enjoy time with our family, running, hiking, and creative projects. I manage a log cabin in Pine as a short-term rental and enjoy showing others the "essence" of what the Rim Country has to offer.

    Joining the experienced and veteran team at Coldwell Banker in Pine, I am ready to use my skills to assist you with buying or selling a home by providing detailed assistance every step of the way. My love of the area and a motivation to turn your aspirations in to reality make me a trusted resource to help make buying or selling your home in the Rim Country a fun, exciting, and stress-free experience.

    My Client Reviews

    Overall star rating: 5.0
    Past 3 months: N/A

    Ratings Breakdown

    Star Rating Percentage of reviews with this rating Number of reviews with this rating
    5 stars
    100% of Amity’s ratings: 5 stars
    4 stars
    0% of Amity’s ratings: 4 stars
    3 stars
    0% of Amity’s ratings: 3 stars
    2 stars
    0% of Amity’s ratings: 2 stars
    1 stars
    0% of Amity’s ratings: 1 star

    Showing All Reviews (3)

    Show only: 5 stars 4 stars 3 stars 2 stars 1 star show all
    John gave Amity 5 stars out of 5
    Having retained Amity to help us purchase a vacation home in Pine during the summer of 2020, we think Amity is the gold standard in Realtors, and we give her our highest and strongest recommendation. To say that Amity goes the "extra mile" to ensure her clients are happy with her service, really doesn't do justice to how we feel about her...she exceeded our expectations in every way possible. A few examples: 1) When our COE was at risk due to a mistake by our lender, Amity drove down to Phoenix so we could sign a document (2 hrs one way) 2) Amity provided property access to internet installation tech when appt had to be rescheduled to weekday due to last-minute COE pushout 3) Getting a contractor in small community like Pine can be a challenge, but Amity lives in the area and always seems to know someone, or be able to find someone, who can provide repair/maintenance/upgrade services 4) Throughout the entire process, Amity was cheerful and pleasant, communicative and responsive, professional and friendly, just extremely easy to work with. 5) When we had to drive up to Pine unexpectedly on a Friday afternoon because of ANOTHER lender error, Amity felt so badly for us (even though absolutely NOT her fault...) that she offered to let us stay in her Air B&B for a night so we wouldn't need to drive up, sign, turn around and drive back down. While we couldn't take her up on her generous offer, we very much appreciated the thought/gesture. 6) We are interested in potentially offering our property as a short-term rental at some point in the future, so were very interested in Amity's thoughts on marketability of our property, rental rates, etc. As Amity has several STR's in Pine, she's an excellent resource. I could keep going, but I'll stop there. If you're looking to purchase a property in the Payson/Pine/Strawberry region, do yourself a favor and talk to Amity...she is exceptionally good at what she does.
    Chris & Cindy gave Amity 5 stars out of 5
    We feel so blessed working with Amity. We had little knowledge about the market and area, but after a few days with Amity by our side, we had a better understanding of what we were looking for and what areas we wanted to search. She went above and beyond the normal scope of her job, making us feel like we were important and taken care of. We love our Cabin and the area we found. I know Amity's the reason we got exactly what we wanted. Thank you!!!!
    Ken gave Amity 5 stars out of 5
    Amity worked tirelessly to keep out house in front of potential buyers. We chose to list our house despite the sudden onset of the COVID-19 shut-down, so conditions for the rapid sale were horrible. However, Amity was steadfast in her resolve to present the house in the best possible light and to promote it in social media, magazines, and even in potential markets beyond our local area. She was concerned and caring about our feelings and always discussed her marketing plans with us. She staged several "Open House" events to capture as much interest as possible, even though the pandemic had reduced the normal traffic through town to a crawl. Being fully aware of the circumstance and the value of our home, she encouraged us to remain steady on the price of our house, and not to panic while the market was slow. We met our first offer with celebration, and accepted it. However the buyer backed out of the deal. Amity had us back on the market within 24 hours and had a buyer in about a week. Her faith and encouragement meant the world to us. Having bought and sold several houses without the assistance of a realtor, Amity showed us the real value of having a skilled professional working in our interest. Thank you Amity. You're awesome.

    Local Insights

    Follow Me

    Share My Page

    Go Mobile

    Want to take your search on the go and find nearby homes? Download my free mobile app.

    Goto Apple app store to download iOS app Goto Google play store to download the app


    Any services or products provided by third parties are not provided by, affiliated with, or related to Coldwell Banker Real Estate LLC or its affiliated companies.