Map Layers

Shelter Island, NY Real Estate

Shelter Island, New York is located in Suffolk County. Nearby cities and towns include Shelter Island Heights, North Haven, Dering Harbor, Greenport, Greenport West, Sag Harbor, East Marion, Noyack, Southold, Northwest Harbor, Orient, Wainscott, Peconic, Bridgehampton, Springs, East Hampton North, Sagaponack, Cutchogue, New Suffolk, East Hampton, Water Mill, North Sea, Amagansett, Mattituck, Tuckahoe, Southampton, Napeague, Laurel, Shinnecock Hills, Fenwick, Jamesport, Saybrook Manor, Old Saybrook Center, Westbrook Center, Hampton Bays, Northville, Aquebogue, Clinton, Flanders, Montauk, Niantic, East Quogue, Riverhead, Essex Village, Riverside, Madison Center, Waterford, Quogue, Fishers Island, New London, Northampton, Baiting Hollow, Groton, Quiogue, Deep River Center, Westhampton, Groton Long Point, Guilford Center, Westhampton Beach, Long Hill, Poquonock Bridge, and Chester Center. Shelter Island is a rural community with a population of 1,345. The median household income is $64,564. In Shelter Island, 69% of residents are married, and families with children reside in 15% of the households. Half the population of Shelter Island commutes 9 minutes or less to work, with 61% of residents holding white collar jobs and 39% residents holding blue collar jobs. The median age of homes in Shelter Island, NY is 37 years, with 38% of those homes owned, 14% rented, and 47% not occupied. In the previous year, 15 Shelter Island properties were sold. The median sale price of a home in Shelter Island in the previous year was $921,933.

Shelter Island, NY Real Estate Listings


Real Estate Agents near Shelter Island, NY

View All agents

About Schools in Shelter Island, NY

Shelter Island offers a range of educational opportunities with one elementary school and one high school.

Contact a Coldwell Banker® real estate agent to learn more about the schools and school districts in Shelter Island, NY.


Careers near Shelter Island, NY

Are you Ready for a Career in Real Estate?

See if your personality and goals are right for real estate.


Shelter Island, NY Local Market & Demographic Data

Married vs. single

Shelter Island, NY
  • 31% Single
  • 69% Married
New York
  • 55% Single
  • 45% Married

Male VS. Female

Shelter Island, NY
  • 49% Female
  • 51% Male
New York
  • 52% Female
  • 48% Male

Average Age of Citizens in Shelter Island, NY

  • 46
  • 39
  • Shelter Island, NY
  • New York

Average Age of Homes in Shelter Island, NY

  • 37
  • 46
  • Shelter Island, NY
  • New York

Vacant Homes in Shelter Island, NY

  • 47%
  • 9%
  • Shelter Island, NY
  • New York

Average INCOME of Citizens

  • $77,335
  • $82,366
  • Shelter Island, NY
  • New York

Owned Homes vs. Rented Homes

Shelter Island, NY
  • 38% Owned
  • 14% Rented
New York
  • 46% Owned
  • 45% Rented