Shelter Island, NY Real Estate and Homes for Sale

Shelter Island, New York is located in Suffolk County. Shelter Island is a rural community with a population of 1,345. The median household income is $64,564. In Shelter Island, 69% of residents are married, and families with children reside in 15% of the households. Half the population of Shelter Island commutes 9 minutes or less to work, with 61% of residents holding white collar jobs and 39% residents holding blue collar jobs. The median age of homes in Shelter Island, NY is 37 years, with 38% of those homes owned, 14% rented, and 47% not occupied. In the previous year, 15 Shelter Island properties were sold. The median sale price of a home in Shelter Island in the previous year was $921,933.

Nearby Cities

Nearby Zip Codes

Homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY

Map of Shelter Island, NY

Map Layers