Map Layers

Fire Island, NY Real Estate

Fire Island, New York is located in Suffolk County. Nearby cities and towns include West Sayville, Bayport, Ocean Beach, Sayville, Blue Point, Oakdale, Great River, Patchogue, Saltaire, East Islip, Bohemia, East Patchogue, North Patchogue, Bellport, North Great River, Holbrook, Islip Terrace, Islip, Holtsville, North Bellport, Ronkonkoma, Brookhaven, Central Islip, Bay Shore, Medford, Islandia, Brightwaters, Oak Beach-Captree, Lake Ronkonkoma, West Bay Shore, Farmingville, North Bay Shore, Shirley, Brentwood, West Islip, Hauppauge, Nesconset, Yaphank, Mastic Beach, Lake Grove, Baywood, Centereach, Selden, Babylon, Gordon Heights, Village of the Branch, Mastic, North Babylon, Coram, St. James, Deer Park, Moriches, Smithtown, Middle Island, West Babylon, Center Moriches, Gilgo, Lindenhurst, Terryville, Head of the Harbor, Stony Brook, Commack, Stony Brook University, Dix Hills, North Lindenhurst, Nissequogue, Wyandanch, Copiague, Wheatley Heights, Port Jefferson Station, Kings Park, Setauket-East Setauket, East Moriches, Mount Sinai, Amityville, North Amityville, Ridge, Miller Place, Manorville, Elwood, Port Jefferson, East Farmingdale, West Hampton Dunes, Rocky Point, Poquott, East Massapequa, Melville, Belle Terre, East Northport, Sound Beach, Massapequa Park, Old Field, South Huntington, Fort Salonga, South Farmingdale, Eastport, Farmingdale, Greenlawn, Remsenburg-Speonk, East Shoreham, Shoreham, Massapequa, North Massapequa, Old Bethpage, Huntington Station, Northport, Plainedge, West Hills, Centerport, Wading River, Calverton, Seaford, Bethpage, Plainview, Huntington, Westhampton Beach, North Wantagh, Wantagh, Westhampton, Halesite, Woodbury, Levittown, Cold Spring Harbor, Northampton, Huntington Bay, Quiogue, and Bellmore. Fire Island is a rural community with a population of 295. The median household income is $80,624. In Fire Island, 46% of residents are married, and families with children reside in 24% of the households. Half the population of Fire Island commutes 21 minutes or less to work, with 53% of residents holding white collar jobs and 47% residents holding blue collar jobs. The median age of homes in Fire Island, NY is 35 years, with 3% of those homes owned, 1% rented, and 96% not occupied. In the previous year, 27 Fire Island properties were sold. The median sale price of a home in Fire Island in the previous year was $869,171.

Real Estate Agents near Fire Island, NY

View All agents

About Schools in Fire Island, NY

Fire Island offers a range of educational opportunities with one elementary school.

Contact a Coldwell Banker® real estate agent to learn more about the schools and school districts in Fire Island, NY.


Careers near Fire Island, NY

Are you Ready for a Career in Real Estate?

See if your personality and goals are right for real estate.


Cities near Fire Island, NY

Fire Island, NY Local Market & Demographic Data

Married vs. single

Fire Island, NY
  • 54% Single
  • 46% Married
New York
  • 55% Single
  • 45% Married

Male VS. Female

Fire Island, NY
  • 44% Female
  • 56% Male
New York
  • 52% Female
  • 48% Male

Average Age of Citizens in Fire Island, NY

  • 44
  • 39
  • Fire Island, NY
  • New York

Average Age of Homes in Fire Island, NY

  • 35
  • 46
  • Fire Island, NY
  • New York

Vacant Homes in Fire Island, NY

  • 96%
  • 9%
  • Fire Island, NY
  • New York

Average INCOME of Citizens

  • $121,656
  • $82,366
  • Fire Island, NY
  • New York

Owned Homes vs. Rented Homes

Fire Island, NY
  • 3% Owned
  • 1% Rented
New York
  • 46% Owned
  • 45% Rented